20 years of News, rumors, minutiae about The Cure
absolutely. Pink Dream is one of my favorite B-sides of all time. It's better than most of the tunes on WMS.
We could quite easily do this with every album after Disintegration, IMHO.
WMS is perfect as is, IMO. :-)
If only this would have been the case. While we're at it, I would have also replaced Numb with Home and Return with Ocean.
Anything that removes Club America, Numb, and Round & Round & Round from WMS, gets my full support.
And The 13th.
Marc,Agreed, although WMS seems to have suffered from poor song selection more than any of the Cure albums (although The Cure is a close second).Funny thing is, even on their older stuff, the Cure was always leaving gems off. IMO 2 Late could have been an excellent pop song. Granted, I'm not sure it really would have fit the mood of Disintegration, which I imagine is why Robert left it off.The Kiss Me sessions also produced several excellent b-sides that I think were stronger than some of the tracks on the studio album.
I actually like "Club America" better than "A Pink Dream." :o*ducks*
Sigh...oh well! That's that. : P
nah, because then the b-sides would probably have really sucked. i don't hate WMS, like it as is, and love A Pink Dream fitting into the mold of The Cure always releasing great b-sides.until 2000 and on, that is...
"Anything that removes Club America, Numb, and Round & Round & Round from WMS, gets my full support."amen, my man!
Craig: I figured as much. :P
I guess i am one of those rare cure fans that enjoyed WMS. Although I am ashamed to admit, other than "Dread Song" they havent produced anything I really disliked.
I'm almost with you, Craig ;) - except I don't mind numb
I actually have an iTunes play list that has my preferred version of Wild Mood Swings:WantHomeStrange AttractionA Pink DreamMint CarJupiter CrashWaitingNumb TrapTreasureIt Used to Be MeI don't much care for the songs that I left off of that list.I did the same thing for Three Imaginary Boys...
All the B-sides from WMS were excellent!
I think you could safely put all of the WMS B-sides on the album and make it much better.
you can do alot of things to it... but "J" how can you leave off BARE... that's way wrong :)
All the b-sides would have better additions, I for one enjoy Club America, The 13th, and Numb, I could do without This is a Lie, Round and Round, and even Gone, the rest of the album I think was mint. The B-sides though were gems that could have been included in the regular tracklisting, especially the Mint-car single b-sides.
Boah... you're all mad!!!! Club America is fucking awesome. One of the absolute standouts of Wild Mood Swings. A Pink Dream is good but definitely has a B-Side feeling to it. Adonais and It used to be me should have been on the album instead of Mint Car and Round&Round&Round. Want Club America This Is a Lie The 13th It Used To Be Me Strange Attraction Jupiter Crash Adonais Gone! Numb Return Trap Treasure Bare...this would have been an awesome follow up to Wish. But nevertheless WMS is beautiful in the way it is. Can't see all to hate for Club America but then on the other side alot of Cure Fans like All I Want or now The Real Snow White. Club America kicks both their asses, easily!!!Okay... just my 50 cent. ;)
I love WMS! When i was 12 i went through my dad's cds and it caught my eye. it was the first Cure record i'd ever heard and it's what got me into them! (i'm 18 now and they are my all-time-favorite-i'd-do-anything-to-see-them-live-a-4th-time band).that being said, i'd much rather have it replace Round & Round... than Club America. i love A Pink Dream. AND i also love Home. I just can't choose!
LOVE Pink Dream. I still say its a felony criminal offense that it was left off the album. But I also love me some Club America. So can we ditch Round & Round & Round & Round & Round & Round instead?
i also really like this album. it sounds like they had a lot of fun while they recorded it. i also like the idea of using real strings. the swing tour showed how much fun they had that year as well (imo their best tour ever!).
no! replace no songs! WMS is a near-flawless album. while the b-sides are all great as well, i think the album works perfectly as a whole as it is.
I love Club America !Don't care much for Round x 3 , Gone and the last two.Every b-side from that album should have been on there.I was really dissappointed by the album when it came out. I've come to appreciate it more as time goes by.
There is no one album with all greatest songs. You always find one song is better then others. B-sides phenomenon is great. It's a balance, a compensation for 'bad' songs. And everyone has a possibility to customise album as everybody wants. It's just waste of time imho
keeep the 13th ,, its fuckin acedrop the hideous middle section ,jc,sa,rrr,gone.. replace with bsides = amazing album!
i still like the songs i dont like on the album just not on the album as a whole... but a second rate cure song is still 20 times better than the majority of the dross out there
ps checkout miserylab
... I love The 13th.(two chord cool)
I see your point Deadboycraved, but Jupiter Crash? Phew!,that's hardly a second rate Cure song,IMO.My Ipod WMS has IUTBM, APD and Ocean on there instead of CA, Gone and numb. Love all the other tracks.
pjw,, yup jupitercrash - to my ears its standard fare cure by numbers- twee whimsical unadulerated evil , lol .i can easily live without this arena of the cures back catalogue ,, the kissme bsides, just like heaven , trust,jupitercrash,taking off, before 3 , siren song .. theyre all ok in thenselves but taint my idea of what the cure is to me , giving a false notion of english tea on the lawn crap that doesnt exist in reality . phew ,. thats it lol
If you were to take The Cure's best b-sides and make an album out of it, it'd probably be my 2nd favorite album behind Disintegration.And I can't believe someone actually dared say JC should be left off of WMS!!! >:<
well if we ll liked the same things how dull life would be todd
Spare me the lectures. Relax. It's all in good fun.
lol lectures?im relaxed mr dont fret
WMS should have been...1. Want2. Club America3. This Is A Lie4. Mint Car5. Ocean6. Adonais7. Jupiter Crash8. Numb9. Gone!10. It Used To Be Me11. Trap12. Treasure13. Bare"Return" should have never been released, even on a b-side. I think "Club America" is great, especially the bass line. All the other songs I left off are just OK. I think "The 13th" is interesting; like "The Blood", "If Only Tonight We Could Sleep", "Labrynith" & "Kyoto Song" before in the expansion away from the basic pop/punk sound of The Cure. That is one of the things that sets them apart from all other bands; but "The 13th" is just not as good as the fore mentioned songs.The overall theme of this post rings very true though. "Wild Mood Swings", more than any other of the later albums, suffers from song choices. A real lack of central theme that you could find on prior diverse albums like "Kiss Me" or "The Top" is missing.- Seymour Glass
This comment has been removed by the author.
Wow, what a way to get the conversation going! :)
deadboycraved said..."giving a false notion of english tea on the lawn crap that doesnt exist in reality"LOL! The other songs, fine, but Jupiter Crash?? Me thinks not, good sir. I think WMS is fine the way it is, and maybe it's kind of pointless to mull over it now? I mean, it's not like it's a new album or anything; I think 4:13 is just as manically idiosyncratic. Oh well, at least we get fabulous b-sides!Kate, you're always happy aren't you? I wish you were my neighbor, instead of the insufferable goblins who live above me. XD
I never really understood all the hate WMS gets. Yeah it's B-sides are better than some of the A sides but isn't that true of all Cure albums?I would rather have the crazy eccentricities and textures of WMS over the (IMO) half hearted dullness of Bloodflowers any day.
-its good no one agrees i think .. that everyone can like somethings and hate others , thats the best thing about them bananafish ,, .i LOVE return ,, i think its the best POPpopPOP song the cure have ever done
Wild Mood Swings was a fantastic album, and it spawned an even greater live tour with it, the Swing Tour! WMS in my opinion, was the last album that Robert sounded like he really cared, or was at least inspired. Maybe it was the the afterglow of comming off the Wish tour and the invincibility of having been one of the biggest bands in the world at the time, but Robert and the rest of the band seemed to actually really enjoy what they were doing. I think they lost it soon after the Bloodflowers tour. Ok, off topic, but all the B-sides from WMS were fantastic as per usual..
Helsa - You are so sweet!
Craig: LMAO. I love *most of WMS, but I agree with you. His vocals on some of those songs really scare and confuse me!
WantAdonaisThis Is A Lie (ambient)A Pink DreamMint Car (Buskers mix)Jupiter CrashWaitingBurnMore Than This
So I just made an iTunes playlist of all the genuinely good material the Cure did after Wish and its singles (hence starting with the Hendrix cover in 1993), not counting live and acoustic versions of older stuff, and allowing only one rendition of each song. I (perhaps generously) came up with 2 hours and 15 minutes, which makes for 3 great 45-minute albums. I suspect that if in the last 16 years, they'd released just the following songs, their legacy would be invincible:Purple HazeBurnDredd SongMint Car (Buskers)AdonaisWaitingA Pink DreamThis Is A Lie (Ambient Mix)WantJupiter CrashMore Than ThisOut Of This WorldWhere The Birds Always SingMaybe SomedayThe Last Day Of Summer39BloodflowersAlt.End (single edit)AnniversaryTaking OffSleep When I'm Dead (Gerard Way & Julien K)Without YouUnderneath The StarsThe Only OneThe Reasons WhySirensongThe Hungry GhostThe Perfect BoyThe End Of The World
I actually like Club America and it's the perfect song for the current lineup to play. I also really like Trap and Treasure. How could anyone leave off Jupiter Crash? Anyways, my version of WMS (on Rhapsody) leaves off a chunk of four songs in a row. Will have to give the B-sides a listen to again.
What comes to WMS it is pretty clear that the problem lies with a poor and not so coherent production. Songs itself, by origin, are not so bad. Just listen to demos of WMS, you will realise the difference. The shortcomings made are similar with that of The Top. A Pink Dream, however, exceed the actual quality of WMS and is definetly better than most of the songs. While with the Cure 2004 album, there is nothing you can do about the poor quality...
i love "the cure " barr 2 or 3 songs .. again the bsides more than make up fr those though
i would replace a lot of the other WMS crap first(R&R&R, Gone, Numb). Most of the b-sides would've made better album tracks. Having done that, the album would've been an instant classic IMHO. In particular, "it used to be me" is F-ing mindblowing!
adonais did kick ass--it was so theatric sounding. anyone know what it was written for? to me, it sounded very much like it was made for a soundtrack and not for WMS. i liked club america too.
anyone who says numb is worth a damn is wrong./official feelingswms never gets a fair shake and thats because half of it is brilliant and the other half is crap. but ALL the b-sides are sterling and a goodness.
i thought it was a good album one of my favs i think the really good songs on there are stronga and the pop is what it is.want is great and mint car is one of my favs on the album as for the b side put everything together it is some of thier best work over all